Appeal Court affirms N5m judgement against Deeper Life Church for trespassing on Celestial Church land

Appeal Court affirms N5m judgement against Deeper Life Church for trespassing on Celestial Church land

The Court of Appeal, Lagos Division has upheld the judgement of Justice Samuel Candide-Johnson of a Lagos high court, which ordered the Registered Trustees of Deeper Christian Life Ministry to pay N5 million as damages for trespassing on a parcel of land belonging to the Celestial Church of Christ (CCC).

Celestial Church of Christ had through its representative; Joseph Ebhodaghe sued Deeper Life Church over the disputed land measuring approximately 1055.864 squares situated at Mulero area of Agege and registered as No- 75 volume 2004T at the Lagos State land registry, Ikeja.

At the lower court, Justice Candide-Johnson had in his judgement delivered on January 17, 2014, declared the Celestial Church of Christ as the rightful owner of the disputed land, and awarded N5 million as damages against Deeper Life Church.

The court also granted a perpetual injunction restraining Deeper Life Church, its agents or servants from further trespass on the disputed land.

Dissatisfied, Deeper Life Church through its lawyer, Gabriel Akigbe appealed against the judgment, and urged the court to set the entire judgement aside on the grounds that the trial judge was perverse having regards to the documentary and oral evidence placed before the court.

But in a unanimous decision, the appellate court comprising of Justice Chinwe Iyizoba (presiding), Justice Yargata Nimpar and Justice Abimbola Obaseki-Adejumo held that the appeal is unmeritous and dismissed same accordingly.

In her lead judgment, Justice Abimbola Obaseki-Adejumo resolved all the six issues in contention in favour of the respondent.

Justice Obaseki-Adejumo observed that both parties traced their titles ownership to the Olalabi-Sulu family but held that the title presented by the Celestial Church is superior to that of Deeper Life Church.

The court pointed out that the respondent (CCC) obtained its title in 1973 as against that of Deeper Life Church which was obtained 1998.

The court held that ‘‘in resolving proof of title to land in a case of competing interest , it is beyond doubt that later in time of the two parties to obtain the grant maintain an action against the party who first obtained a valid grant of the land from such a common grant”.

Justice Obaseki-Adejumo held that the trial judge rightly interpreted the evidence led and applied the law when he held that the respondent’s title is superior to that of the appellant.

Beside, the appellate court held that the lower court judge judicially and judiciously carried out its duty to evaluate the documentary evidence as well as oral evidence presented before the court.

On the issue of N5 million damages, the court held ‘’I am unable to agree that damages awarded was excessive, having deprived the respondent the use of the land from 1995 till judgment and erected structures on the land. Coupled with consistent frustrating acts which are evident on the record.’’


Related Articles

TEENAGE STUDENT WHO STABBED NIGERIAN TEACHER IN ARGUMENT OVER PHONE JAILED

The 14-year-old student who stabbed his Nigerian teacher, Vincent Uzomah in front of his classmates in the UK, has been

Poisoned Rice Flood Nigerian Markets

Poisoned foreign rice smuggled into the country may have flooded Nigerian market through Seme, Idiroko, Shaki and Chikanda borders, a

SECURITY MAN ESCAPES LYNCHING AFTER CAUGHT STEALING 3 SIBLINGS

A man working as a security man at Alaba International Market was nearly lynched by a mob at the weekend


x

Other Interesting Posts

Ali Modu Sheriff's aircraft reportedly seized
An aircraft that belongs to Peoples Democratic Party, PDP, factional Chairman, Ali Modu Sheriff, has been seized by the Economic and Financial Cr...
Bill protecting dead bodies from ritualists passed
The House of Representatives on Tuesday passed bill protecting the right of the dead to rest in perfect peace citing many instances of abuse of t...
Ambode queries artistes on trip to South Africa
Governor Akinwunmi Ambode on Tuesday sought out opportunities for collaboration between his government and artistes. Read also: Apostle Psalm ...
powered by RelatedPosts